Since the season began, it's pretty much been assumed that Florida Panthers defenseman Jay Bouwmeester would be the ultimate prize at this year's trade deadline. A 25-year-old defenseman just beginning to hit his prime, Bouwmeester is playing out the final year of his contract on a team that's been a perenial bottom-feeder in the Eastern Conference. As it turns out, the Panthers are a pretty good hockey team, currently in a four-way battle for the final two playoff spots in the conference. It's unlikely that Bouwmeester is going to re-sign in Florida, leaving general manager Jacques Martin with quite a dilemma: does he keep Bouwmeester in an effort to make the playoffs, knowing he's probably going to lose him after the season? Or does he attempt to cash in his chips and deal his most marketable player? It should be a no-brainer.
The Panthers haven't qualified for the postseason in nine years and are currently playing before the smallest crowds (in terms of percentage) in the NHL. They need to make the playoffs.
On Sunday, Ray Slover of The Sporting News offered up this suggestion on what to do with Bouwmeester: "Would GM Jacques Martin be best served by getting two teams into a bidding war for Bouwmeester? It's a logical way to boost the defenseman's value."
Sure, it's a logical way to boost his value. But why are you boosting his value? Entering play on Sunday the Panthers (tied with Buffalo) have a five-point advantage over Carolina and Pittsburgh, with an opportunity to widen that gap to seven points with a win against Washington. They're only three points behind Philadelphia for the No. 4 spot in the conference. Trading Bouwmeester, or anybody that is a critical part of the team, shouldn't even be a thought, offseason contract status be dammed.
Nine. Year. Playoff. Drought.
First, let's take a look at who would be likely to swing a deal for Bouwmeester in a hypothetical March 4 trade.
Contenders.
Obviously, a team out of the playoff hunt isn't going to give up anything of consequence for a player that's going to be walking out of town to the highest bidder in two months anyway.
On Saturday, George Martin of the Miami Herald mentioned how the Panthers are still talking to Bouwmeester, while also talking to other teams about what they have to offer.
He says he won't make a move just to add a player, not with the team playing so well. ''If I can improve the team, I will,'' he said. He also alluded to Jay not necessarily wanting to stay in Florida, saying there are plenty of players who do want to play for the Panthers. He used Cory Stillman signing here as a free agent and Bryan McCabe waiving his no-trade to come south.The only way a trade makes sense for Florida is if it gets something back in return that could bolster the team's playoff chances this season (a goal-scorer, perhaps? Perhaps a young, puck-moving defenseman kind of like Jay Bouw... hey, wait a minute), and it's doubtful a contender is going to part with such a player in the middle of a playoff race.
I think when March 5 rolls around Bouwmeester will still be wearing a Panthers sweater. After all, the team recently came out with The Panthers Promise Plan, a ticket package that gives fans free tickets to four games next season if the team misses the playoffs this year.
If they trade Bouwmeester and miss the playoffs as a result, it's doubtful they'll even be able to give those tickets away for free.
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-15-2009 @ 5:54PM
Scott said...
Search Randy Moller Goal Calls
Reply
2-16-2009 @ 11:03AM
Colonial said...
Will it be worth it to make the playoffs as the 7th or 8th seed only to get murdered by Boston or the Caps? The Panthers should only keep Bouwmeester if they think they are a team that can truly make some noise in the postseason. I say they trade him but only if they get a ridiculous offer.
A top prospect, 1st round pick, and a roster player should be where the conversation begins.
Reply
2-16-2009 @ 11:06AM
AdamGretz said...
Considering the amount of revenue a team gets from even one round of the playoffs. Yes. And Florida is within striking distance of the No's 4, 5, or 6 seeds, so it's not like Boston is a guarantee.
2-16-2009 @ 11:41AM
Colonial said...
Yes, if Florida thinks they are going to land as the 4th or 5th seed there is no question they should keep Bouwmeester. However if they are going to be a fringe team they should trade him.
Getting the right trade for JBo will hurt the team this year but it might put the team into a better position for the next several years. Getting into the playoffs one season is not good for business (ask Atlanta). Building a team that can regularly make the playoffs is.
For a comparable situation do you think it was the best move for the Panthers to keep Ollie Jokinen? At this point the team probably wishes they traded him when his stock was higher at the deadline (no offense to Nick Boynton or Keith Ballard intended).
Reply